
6
FINSBURY GROWTH & INCOME TRUST PLC | Annual Report 2024
STRATEGIC REPORT
PERFORMANCE
As we approach Finsbury’s 100th anniversary and after almost
ten years on your Board I am very aware of how essential it
is that investment managers have a long-term perspective.
However, managing funds over such time horizons is inevitably
difficult and I am disappointed to report another year of
underperformance by your Company when measured
against the performance of the benchmark, the FTSE All-Share
Index. While the Company’s long-term track record remains
impressive, this will provide little solace to more recent
investors for whom returns will be substantially below what
they may have hoped for.
The Company’s net asset value (“NAV”) per share delivered a total
return of 8.2% over the financial year compared with a benchmark
total return of 13.4%. The share price return over the same period
was 3.4%, reflecting a widening of the discount to NAV.
In the face of this ongoing period of challenging performance
your Board has continued to provide constructive challenge
to the Portfolio Manager, regularly reviewing the investment
process, portfolio themes and individual holdings throughout
the year. The Board has also undertaken a series of meetings
with institutional Shareholders (representing approximately a
third of the Company’s share capital), to ascertain their views
of the Company and the extent of their continued support for
the investment approach. While no one wants to experience
a prolonged period of underperformance, it is clear that there
remains significant support from investors for the Company’s
concentrated investment portfolio. No Shareholder has
expressed to us any appetite for a material change in approach.
We are grateful for this continued support but do not take it for
granted. With that in mind, and as part of broader shareholder
engagement, your Board will hold a continuation vote after
the current financial year ends in September 2025 (expected
to be held at the Company’s AGM in January 2026). This will
offer all Shareholders, in particular our retail shareholders who
represent a significant proportion of our register, an opportunity
to express their support, or otherwise, for the continuation of the
Company with its current investment strategy.
Chairman’s Statement
Simon Hayes, Chairman
In the meantime, your Board remains committed to buying
back shares, as described in more detail below, aware of the
value of the additional liquidity an active buy-back strategy
offers and of the enhancement in net asset value that
buy-backs provide. In the past financial year, the Company
has bought back over £310 million worth of its own shares
which is more then three times the value bought back in 2023.
As it is always important to point out, a highly concentrated
portfolio means higher risk, particularly in the short term. At
30September 2024, the Company’s Active Share – a measure
of how much it varies from the FTSE All-Share Index benchmark
- was 84.1% (2023: 85.3%). Such an uncorrelated portfolio will
inevitably perform very differently from the wider market,
whether positively or negatively.
I urge you to read Nick Train’s very helpful review where he
discusses the reasons for the relative underperformance and
explains why he holds the top ten holdings of the portfolio and
why he is optimistic for better future returns.
SHARE BUY-BACKS
As at 30 September 2024 the discount to NAV was 8.7%
(2023:4.4%). During the year under review the Company
bought back a total of 36,801,766 shares (18.0% of the shares in
issue) at a cost of over £310 million (2023: £97.7 million) and at
an average discount of 7.4%. This resulted in the NAV per share
being 14p higher than it would otherwise have been.
As at the close of the UK market on 2 December 2024, the
discount was 8.5%. Since the year end, a further 9,913,457
shares have been bought back at a cost of £85.3 million. As at
2December 2024, the Company had 157,804,211 shares in issue
(excluding 67,187,092 shares held in Treasury).
While share buy-backs will not necessarily prevent a discount
from widening further, particularly in times of market volatility,
they may, to a limited extent, mitigate a widening trend. In
addition, buy-backs enhance the NAV per share for remaining
Shareholders, provide some additional liquidity and help to
dampen discount volatility which can damage Shareholder
returns.
Discounts are affected by many factors outside the Company’s
control, including investor sentiment towards the Company, the
sector and towards equity markets in general, but where it is in
Shareholders’ interests (taking account of market conditions),
the Company remains committed to buying back shares at a
discount to NAV, as demonstrated over the past year.
Reflecting the Company’s commitment to buying back shares,
the Company held a General Meeting in August 2024 to renew
Shareholder authority to buy-back shares when it became
clear that the Shareholder authority to buy-back 14.99% of the
Company’s share capital granted at the AGM in January 2024
would be exhausted before the expected date of the 2025
AGM. The Company’s share buy-back authority will as usual
be proposed for renewal at the Company’s Annual General
Meeting to be held in January 2025.